How to Handle (Tainted) History
A friend of mine called me last night with an offer to go to the Dodgers game on Thursday. I’ll go see a Major League Baseball game no matter what teams are involved, so it didn’t matter who the Dodgers were playing. It just so happens that the Dodgers will be playing the San Francisco Giants. As of this moment, Barry Bonds stands two home runs shy of owning the all-time home run record. I could conceivably see him tie or even break the record on Thursday—heck, the Dodgers gave up the record-breaking home run to Hank Aaron when he passed Babe Ruth in 1974. We’ll be sitting high in the left field bleachers, so the chances of us catching the home run are incredibly slim unless Bonds breaks his tendency and hits a deep, opposite field blast. But Bonds does play in left field, so I will get to bask in the creative and utterly foul heckling that only disenfranchised Raiders fans in the bleachers of Dodger Stadium can produce. I for one do believe that Bonds has broken the spirit of the rules of baseball and has taken performance enhancing drugs—people generally don’t grow two shoe sizes in their late thirties—so I am not a fan of him breaking this record. Aaron was and is pure class. Bonds, suffice it to say, is not. But if Bonds does break it, I’d like to be there.
Here is my question to you: if you were at the game, how would you respond to Bonds tying or breaking Aaron’s record?
- Cheer wildly for Bonds, one of baseball’s greatest players breaking a monumental record.
- Cheer wildly for the record, an historic feat that though perhaps not gained entirely fairly, is still a sizable achievement.
- Clap politely with respect for the career of Bonds and/or the record.
- Sit silently or turn your back on Bonds as he rounds the bases as a protest of contempt for someone who has no respect for the game and only sought personal glory.
- Whenever Bonds comes to bat, leave the stands. (A kind of a further step of the previous option.)
- Boo, cry to the heavens in lament, rip your clothes in shreds, bring a container of ashes, pour them on your seat, and sit in them for the rest of the game.
- Moon Bonds, give him the finger, make such a spectacle that you get yourself thrown out of the game and banned from all future MLB games anywhere.
- Other. Please describe.
My friend says he wants to bring a giant foam asterisk. I told him I would dig up a giant foam syringe or a giant foam medicinal tube. I doubt we’ll be able to find these items before Thursday night. Also, I’m an Oakland A’s fan so I have no love or loyalty to either the Giants or the Dodgers. My concern is more as a fan of the game and respect for its records. Unsavory characters have held all sorts of records in baseball, such as the all-time hits record. The last two men to have that record were Ty Cobb and Pete Rose—people who were both ugly marks on baseball. I’d still rather see men of good character succeed. Aaron is one of those men.
UPDATE: We didn’t witness history last night. Bonds went 1-2 and two walks. His hit was a single into right field in the second inning. After the Dodgers walked him in the seventh inning, the Giants pulled him for a pinch runner. The left field pavilion actually proved underwhelming. The fans were loud and incessantly heckled Bonds when he was on defense, but the jeers were generally uncreative. Lots insults calling him a cheater, chants of “ster-oids, ster-oids,” several BALCO statements, but nothing all that original. Aside from seeing a couple fans entering the stadium wearing lab coats with BALCO references, the one truly creative piece of heckling I saw was an inflatable syringe with muscular arms wearing Bond’s number, 25. Of course security removed this item, but not as quickly as you might think. Giants fans received a lot of grief, and that is to be expected because of the rivalry between the Dodgers and the Giants, but I wish Los Angeles fans would find some more interesting and original insult than calling any San Francisco fan some version of a homosexual epithet. That stereotype was old twenty years ago. One unintentionally funny statement came when a fan made an attempt at eloquence when he said in response to something his friend yelled to Bonds, “Sorry Barry, he went too far. On behalf of myself, I would like to apologize.” I think the intention was to apologize on behalf of his friend. It reminded me of Mrs. Slocombe’s repeated declaration, “And I am unanimous in this!” in Are You Being Served? (I bet you didn’t think I would drop a 1970’s British sitcom reference in a post on baseball, did you?) I thought the fans did a better job heckling Colorado Rockies’ left fielder Matt Holliday last year as he was just starting to make a name for himself. The Dodgers fans didn’t know who Holliday was from Adam, which forced them to be creative in their insults.


You’re just bitter that the A’s are basically out of the playoffs (yes, as are the giants) AND you have nothing left to root for.
Did you cheer when McGuire broke the record? Go on and cheer for Bonds. He’s got an amazing swing.
Comment by Matt Barber — July 31, 2007 @ 8:58 pm
I’m not bitter as an A’s fan. I’m angry as a baseball fan. I did cheer for McGwire and Sosa in 1998, but if I knew then what I know now, I would have likely not cheered and would have been just as upset.
One of the things that bothers me so much is that Bonds was already one of the greatest players ever before he transformed his body. What he’s doing now appears to me as superfluous and selfish.
Comment by Tyler Watson — August 1, 2007 @ 7:57 am
The major problem with these guys is that they are breaking records held by athletes of past generations, most of whom did not have access to steroids (i’m not sure of this point. When did steroids become available?) So, what would Hank or Babe have been able to do had they been shooting up?
Comment by Matt Barber — August 1, 2007 @ 12:45 pm
oops. There was more to that arguement (defending Bonds) that got lost somehow. No time to retype. We’ll talk about this later.
Comment by Matt Barber — August 1, 2007 @ 12:47 pm
The major problem is not that these athletes are breaking records held by athletes who didn’t have access to the same substances. The athletes of previous generations did not have access to a lot of the sports technologies that are legal within baseball today. Babe Ruth got in shape over an off-season by boxing and chopping wood on his farm. Today he would have a personal trainer monitoring his diet, putting him on supplements, and putting him through rigorous weight training. The major problem is that these current athletes are taking substances that radically change the chemistry of their bodies. These are substances not regulated by the FDA and are likely illegal. These athletes are cheating. Yes, it appears a lot of MLB players have juiced or taken amphetamines in the last several years. Bonds likely faced several pitchers on some form of steroids. That means they’re all cheating. Two wrongs don’t make a right.
The best way to compare athletes is with those of their same era. Baseball statistics are alluring in that they tempt us to think that all external variables are similar, but it isn’t so. Players before Ruth played in the dead ball era. Ruth never traveled far, didn’t face black pitchers, and never played a night game. Gibson and Koufax pitched on a higher mound with a more generous strike zone and Aaron was still hitting home runs at a good clip during that era. Bonds will need to be compared to the juicers and all the juicers need to have asterisks by their records. But we can’t prove all who did and didn’t cheat, so what do we do? Because of that difficulty, I can say Bonds will own the record outright, but I will maintain that he gained the much of the record through ill-gotten means.
Steroids were readily available at least as early as the 1970’s, if not sooner. Yet we didn’t see that crap emerge en force until the late-80’s and especially in the mid-90’s.
Comment by Tyler Watson — August 1, 2007 @ 1:14 pm
Tyler,
I would have to employee an appropriate mixture of options #4 and #7. I wouldn’t be interested in being removed altogether. I have been a staunch supporter of the asterisk since the means of McGuire/Sosa became public. Simple, consistency requires me to apply this same rational to Mr. Bonds. I belive Mr. Bonds and his ilk have ended an important American era. As in a previous post all comparisons to the past are no longer compatible. These “cheaters” (who run rampant in the mlb) while making short-term gains have unconsciously jeopardized the sport, as we knew it. I cannot with clear conscience celebrate MBL achievements with my son. For this I view these men just as I would watch a thief in the night.
Comment by Joshua C. Watson — August 15, 2007 @ 4:59 pm