For those who don’t know, Sufjan Stevens is streaming his five Christmas albums over on the Asthmatic Kitty website. Take a listen to awesome renditions of classics, often with interesting twists on their titles. (I’ve put the title of the album on which the songs appear for easy reference.) “Away in a Manger” (Vol. 4, Joy) with a banjo? Fantastic! “Holy, Holy, etc.” (Vol. 1, Noel)? Splendid! “O Come O Come Emmanuel” (Vol. 3, Ding! Dong!)? It’ll make you cry. He busts out nearly obsolete carols and hymns like, “I Saw Three Ships” (Vol. 2, Hark!) and “Lo! How A Rose E’er Blooming” (Vol. 5, Peace) with such gentle craft that you wonder why they ever went away. And then there are his original compositions. I recommend “Put the Lights On the Tree” (Vol. 2, Hark!), “Come on! Let’s Boogey to the Elf Dance!” (Vol. 3, Ding! Dong!), “Did I Make You Cry On Christmas Day? (Well, You Deserved It!)” (Vol. 4, Joy), and “Get Behind Me, Santa!” (Vol. 5, Peace).
Listening to these songs gets me in the right Christmas spirit, i.e., a worshipful and awed posture in considering Jesus’ incarnation. I think Stevens has created some of the best Christmas music of the past few decades. Actually, one could argue it’s the only good original Christmas music from a major artist for decades—admittedly, some good covers of classic songs do exist. If you want to argue that Paul McCartney’s “Wonderful Christmastime” should be considered as a good original Christmas tune, you’re going to get a knuckle sandwich from me. To employ a phrase from Anne Lamott, that song makes “Jesus want to drink gin straight out of the cat dish.”







